Sketch of Proposed Cemetery Sign

The Pioneer Methodist Cemetery

Approximate Cemetery List


Home Page      History      [Cemetery List]      Veterans Page      Picture Page      Directions & Map      How To Help
In the Media      Contact Us      About the Author      Site Map
Pioneer Methodist Cemetery
Campbell, Mahoning County, Ohio
Contributions by Sherrie Mazon and Sue Mazon on 1 Aug 2006
Other Data Added From the Records of Florence Galida, and On-Site Reads 
 
Last Name First Name Birth Date Death Date Other
Allerton John L. 1801 1/17/1852 Betta, his wife-
Anderson Jesse C. 1881 1928  
Anderson John. R. 1847 1885 78th PA, Civil War Soldier (Section B Row 5½)
Anderson Selena F. 1845 1938 A researcher taped a note to the tombstone, stating that Selena's father was Emanuel Wharfel and mother was Sarah E. Shade.
Armitage Ella P. 1866 1868  
Armitage James 1837 1924  
Armitage Lydia A. 1842 1909 Wife of James Armitage
Armitage Mary   5/30/1854  
Armstrong Sarah K. 1839 1907  
Atkinson Ann 1818 1902 Wardle family Stone
Atkinson George   1818 1887  
Augustine Daniel   1857 Civil War Soldier (G.A.R) (Section B Row 11)
Augustine Catherine     Date Obliterated
Augustine A.D 8/24/1817 9/13/1886  
Augustine Margaret 2/6/1820 11/30/1895 wife of A.D 
Beggs David 1790 4/4/1857 Age 67
Beggs Mary ? 2/23/1848  
Bell Elizabeth D. 1/1/1800 11/1/1882 Mother of R.N. Fitch, located in R. N. Fitch Plot
Bennett Charles E.   1/17/2001  
Biggs ? ? ? No other information known
Boak A.Y ? ? Dates unknown
Bott Clyde 1880 1959 (Son of Henry & Magdalene)
Bott Henry 1844 1904 Co. F. 187 Ohio Inf. (Father) Civil War (Section A Row 7) (Father of Clyde, Husband of Magdalene)
Bott Magdalene 1846 1905 (Married to Henry & Mother of Clyde)
Bott Nora 1875 1951 (Married to William & Mother of Florance Bott)
Bott Florence 1910 1986 (Daughter of William and Nora)
Bott William 1867 1944 (Husband of Nora & Father)
Brackenridge William 1811 8/10/ 1851 Aged 40 years
Brockman Dollie Vail 1871 1938  
Brockman Lewis F. 1872 1938  
Brockman Harry 1/1/? 1/2/1903 Son
Brockman Anna M. Vail 11/4/1868 6/28/1934  
Brooks Theodore   1877 1935  
Brooks Birdella 1880 1940 Wife of Theodore
Brooks Mary Brooke Decker 1885 1906  
Brown Grace E. 6/30/1899 7/30/1899  
Brownlee Moses 1804 2/13/1887 Aged 82 years 5 months
Brownlee Elizabeth T. 1801 3/11/1871 Aged 61 years
Brownlee Frank 1859 1898 Father
Brownlee Elmira 1856 1942 Mother
Brownlee Ruth 1894 1896 Daughter
Butler Katherine ? ? With Rosenberger Plot
Butler Jane 1890 1924 With Rosenberger Plot
Calhoun Robert 1856 2/27/1866 Aged 10 years
Campbell Daniel S.   4/11/1871 Aged 79 y, 11 m, 11 d
Carpenter Maggie V. 1853 1916  
Carsonie Dorothy 7/8/1925 12/28/1980 Loving Mother
Cephas ? ? ? Mother, Father, 2 Infants
Creed John A. 8/9/1842 2/4/1908  
Creed Caroline 11/18/1846 4/22/1900 Wife of John A.
Creed Gracie 1878 2/28/1888 Aged 9 years, 3 months
Creed Arthur   2/11/1885 Aged 2 months
Creed Susan   1/8/1892 Aged 23 years, 8 months, 5 days
Creed David 1848 1928  
Creed Martha 1848 1923  
Curl John 1837 1883 Dates questionable
Curl John 1860 ?  
Curl William, Sr. 1854 1936  
Curl Hannah 1857 1931 Wife of William, Sr.
Curl Mary M. Curl Evans 1879 1902  
Curl William 12/28/1891 4/19/1969 World War I Veteran (Section A Row 11)
Curl Esther Myers Curl 4/27/1896 1/26/1971  
Curl W. Richard 1920 1944 U.S. Airforce-World War II (Section A Row 11)
Decker Mary 1885 1906 With Brooks Plot
Doughton Dorothy Thomas 1881 1964  
Doughton Wallace 1884 1933  
Eschleman Cora 1862 1964 Dates questionable
Evans Helen B. 1895 1964 Mother
Evans William W. Jr. 11/18/1921 1/4/1963 Ohio Tec 5 Btry A 151 Fld. Arty. BN World War II (Section A, Row 2)
Evans William Sr. 1896 1969  
Fankle Andrew D. 1876 1924  
Fankle Anna M. Vail 1878 1911  
Fitch R. N. 10/18/1822 9/17/1901  
Fitch Jane 10/6/1826 11/9/1884 Wife of R. N.
Fitch Frank L. 1/18/1862 8/22/1864 Son of R.N.
Fitch Mary A. 8/22/1853 10/20/1925  
Fitch Myrtle ? ?  
Fitch Charles W. 1856 1918  
Fitch Sadie A. 1864 1922 Wife of Charles W.
Fitch George William 10/29/1927 6/26/1999 World War II Veteran (Section C Row 13)
Fitch Julia 1/29/1858 3/7/1859  
Fitch Loretta 2/14/1906 12/9/1996  
Fitch Raymond G. 5/5/ 1890 3/24/1973 OH Pvt. US Army WWI (Section C Row 13)
Fitch William Howard   4/7/1954 Infant Son
Fleet George ? 1881 Son of Ruchard & Ann Fleet
Franklin Francis ? ?  
Frease Amy Luella 1860 1949  
Frease William D. 1852 1935  
Gustavsen Inez D.   12/14/1913 Wife of M.F. Gustavsen
Harris Hamilton ? ?  
Harris Candace 5/28/1830 8/8/1874 Wife of Hamilton
Harris Annie 8/7/1859 8/13/1868  
Harris Eddie 11/13/1862 8/29/1865  
Harris Elva 7/19/1864 8/19/1865  
Harris ? ? ? (Husband)
Harris Lavina 3/7/1833 5/16/1893 (Wife of unknown male above)
Haney  Seth B. ? ? Name questionable, Son of D. & M. Haney
Haney  Barbara ? ?  
Hardesty Harriet A. 1834 1869 Wife of Hugh D. Hardesty
Hardesty Hugh D. 1826 1889 Civil War Soldier (G.A.R) (Section B, Row 2)
Harvey John A. ? 1881  
Harvey William ? ?  
Harvey Susan 1866 1939  
Hendrick John 1887 1964  
Hendrick Lena 1892 1948 Wife of John A.
Hendrick John 1915 1924  
Hendrick Joseph 10/15/1925    
Hendrick Margaret 11/10/1927    
Hendrick ? ? ? (Husband)
Hendrick Jesse    1891 1959 (Wife of unknown male above)
Hershey William P. 1878 1968  
Hershey Nellie D. 1883 1950  
Hershey Rollin ? ?  
Hershey Nancy Gilmore 1910 1911  
Hershey Infant 1922 1922  
Hershey Collin       
Hershey Mary Gilmore      
Hershey Nellie D. 1883 1950  
Hershey William D. 1878 1968  
Higgins Shirley 1936   (With Hershey Plot)
Higgins Durbey   1937  
Hoover Mary ? ?  
Hoover John ? ?  
Houston Flora M.   2/9/1885 Aged 24 years, 5 months, 11 days; Wife of A. A. Houston & Daughter of W. & E. Vail; Located in Vail Plott
Jackson Martin E. 12/28/1949 7/26/2000 USMC Vietnam Veteran (Section C Row 13)
Jackson Veronica B. 1911 1981  
Jackson William J. 1909 1977 "Bill the Tinner"
Jackson William J. Jr. 8/8/1924 12/26/2000  
Jacobs Isabella B. 5/4/1813 2/18/1836 1st Wife of Nicholas
Jacobs Nicholas 1/13/1810 12/14/1880  
Jacobs Juliana 9/25/1820 7/5/1904 3rd Wife of Nicholas
Jacobs Clarinda 6/1/1859 9/30/1863  
Jacobs Charles 7/24/1841 9/30/1863 Civil War Soldier (G.A.R) (Section B, Row 7) Killed at Chickamauga, GA during Civil War
Jacobs Phebe 3/24/1850 9/19/1851  
Jacobs Jessie 11/28/1857 12/2/1870  
Jacobs William Henry 5/21/1861 12/17/1882  
Jacobs Myron 8/6/1854 6/21/1892  
Jones Helen Evans 11/22/1923 5/21/1992 For My sake, and in My name, live on.
Kimmel Tobias 6/1802 1/20/1880  
Kimmel Rebecca 8/4/1802 3/6/1866 Wife of Tobias
Kimmel Isaac 1769 8/27/1851 Came to Youngstown in 1802
Kimmel Anna   1774 10/1858 Wife of Isaac
Kimmel Roger? ? ?  
Kimmel Phillip 10/19/1827 7/14/1849  
Kimmel Susan 11/28/1796 3/15/1850 Wife of Phillip Kimmel (1793-4/3/1873) Both Now Buried in Oak Hill Cemetery, Youngstown. Susan Was Moved, by order of Phillip's Executor.
Keesecker Susannah   1840 54 years old
Logan Alexander   12/5/1894 3/1/1917  
Long Ann 1824 1894 Wife of Henry Long
Long Henry 1816 1882  
Louis John 1800 1873  
Loveland Elizabeth 8/7/1780 6/18/1881 Wife of William McFarland
Mariner Ephraim Wick 10/03/1826 8/16/1849  
Mariner Sarah K. 1836 1917  
Mariner Ira A. 1827 1886  
Mariner Azariah D. 5/22/1830 3/27/1899  
Mariner Mary Helen 1880 1889  
Mariner Joseph B.   2/14/1829 Departed this life in the 20th year of his life
Mariner Lot   4/22/1849 Son of I.A & M.J. Mariner, aged 6 weeks
Mariner Mariah D. 8/22/1886  ??/27/ 1899  
Marsteller Art Sr. 2/10/1928 10/3/1995  
Marsteller Delores J. 5/2/1931 12/11/2001  
Mathews Harvey D. 3/5/???? 6/28/1881  
Mathews James G. (unreadable) (unreadable)  
Mathews John A. 9/19/187? 2/10/1881  
Mathews Lorin B. ? ?  
Mathews James F. 1864 ?  
Mathews Elmer 9/8/1865 2/6/1881(87?)  
Mathews William (unreadable) (unreadable)  
McCartney Carrie J. 1870 1951  
McCartney Gertrude E. 1896 1980  
McCartney William B. 1866 1921  
McCartney Joseph G. 7/10/1834 3/10/1910 Civil War Soldier (G.A.R) (Section C Row 12)
McCartney Mary E. 10/25/1840 3/21/1929  
McCartney Minnie F. 5/6/1882 7/28/1897 Daughter
McFarland William 5/3/1780 12/13/1863  
McFarlin William 7/21/1856 4/17/1891  
McFarlin Virgil C. 10/15/1851 7/3/1903  
McFarlin Mary Cooper 4/29/1856 1/28/1927 Wife
Their Children:        
McFarlin Iva Shirley 11/17/1893 6/29/1895  
McFarlin John Carl 12/28/1889 8/3/1898  
McFarlin Hattie Ellen 11/1/1880 4/9/1899  
McFarlin Elmer Ellsworth 6/25/1896 3/28/1900  
 
McFarlin Amos 2/10/1813 6/28/1880 Civil War Soldier (G.A.R) (Section C Row 11)
McGraw Kenneth 11/10/1920 7/4/1921  
McGuffey Catharine 5/1807 2/15/1850 Wife of James Milligan
McIntosh Daniel 8/12/1852 6/20/1899  
McIntosh Daniel H. 1/10/1801 9/10/ 1887  
McIntosh Jane 4/7/1821 7/31/1858 Wife of Daniel H. McIntosh
McIntosh John 1856 1913 Father
McIntosh Frances Sweeney 8/23/1853 4/20/1890 Wife of Daniel  McIntosh (not D.H.)
McIntosh Ann J. 1825 1907 Wife
Milligan Catherine Mcuffey 5/1807 2/25/1850 Wife of James McGuffey
Children of  James & Catherine      
Milligan Alexander D. 7/11/1836 1/26/1850  
Milligan Annie 9/12/1829 7/15/1923  
Milligan James 3/15/1806 3/30/1881 Born in Tyrone, Ireland
 
Milligan Nancy M. Reed 7/31/1823 ? Wife of James Milligan
Children of James and Nancy      
Milligan Julia Fitch 2/9/1858 3/7/1859  
Milligan Martha Eliza 6/29/1853 1857  
 
Milligan William J. 1834 1908  
Milligan Martha T.  1842 1920 Wife of William Milligan
Milligan Catherine M. 1866 1907 Daughter
Milligan N. R. 1860 1928  
Milligan Anna K. 1859 1910 Wife of N. R.
Milligan Mabel C. 1882 1889 Daughter
Moore Martha    1848 1923 Mother
Moore David T. 1848 1928 Father
Moore Grover 1887 1899 Son
Moore Myrtle 1889 1898 Daughter
Moore George 1871 1888 Son
Morgan ? ? ?  
Myers Nora Curl 2/25/1885 8/31/1964  
Myers John Penberthy 1/7/1885 4/24/1956  
Myers John Roy 8/10/1913 12/11/1918  
Polley S. H. 1866 1912  
Predmore W. P.   3/14/1844 Aged 36 years
Predmore William     1811 ?  
         
Price Matilda E. 12/18/1825 12/16/1890 Wife of William Price
Price Sarah C. 9/8/1852 10/7/1859 Daughter of William & Matilda Price
Price William 7/15/1823 8/19/1901  
Ransom Darwin   2/1/1863 Aged 24 years, Son of L. and Margaret Ransom
Ransom John B.   3/1/1861 Aged 23 years
Redfern Levi 1854 1933 Father
Redfern Lucy C. 1857 1892 Mother
Reno Maurine 1911 1972  
Reno Clark 1900 1973  
Reno Sarah C. 1874 1907 Mother
Reno John    1867 1909 Father
Reno Jane 1842 1899 Mother
Reno George 1836 1912 Father
Rosenberger Birdella 1880 1940 Wife of Theodore Brooks Rosenberger
Rosenberger Frederick M. 1852 1914  
Rosenberger Harry 1896 1900  
Rosenberger Katherine 1857 1941 Wife of Frederick M.
Rosenberger Mary Decker 1885 1906  
Rosenberger Theodore Brooks 1877 1935  
Rosenberger Ida ? ?  
Rosenberger Anna ? ?  
Rosenberger William ? ?  
Rosenberger Sidney ? 1976  
Rosine Charles W. 1872 1949  
Rosine Elsie E. 1874 1960 Wife of Charles W.
Rosine Glenn 1896 1899 Son
Rosine Lloyd ? 1975  
Rush John A. 1861 1920  
Rush Annie 1865 1942  
Sawyer James E. Family ? ?  
Schaffert Eva E. Burrows 1870 1937  
Schroeder Margaret ? ? Wife of John Schroeder
Shchuemacher Clyde J. 1894 1956 WWI Veteran  
Seanet Hannah Marita   3/26/1841 9 months and 26 days
Sears John   12/12/1860  
Sears Emily   6/28/1876 Aged 72 years
Shannon ?     Dates Obliterated
Stephens John A.   1840  
Stephens Nancy A.   4/14/1841  
Stephens Emery A.   1/1812 Son of Nancy & John
Stephens Robert   12/17/1812 Aged 21 years
Stephens Hiram L. 1837 1869 Co. C. 171st Ohio Inf. Civil War Soldier (Section A Row 15 ½)
Stephens Ruth A. 1845 1903 Wife of Hiram L.
Stephens Ernest W. 1862 1864 Son of Hiram & Ruth
Stephens John 1792 1874 War of 1812 Soldier (Section B Row 9)
Stephens Margaret 1790 1869 Wife of John Stephens
Stevens Andrew 1847 1923  
Stevens Andrew Jr. 1884 1895  
Stevens Dorothy 1854 1939 Wife of Andrew Stevens
Stewart Daniel A.   1 /??/????  
Stewart Ann K.   1/13/1863 Aged 52 years; Wife of R. Stewart
Stewart Arminda V. ? ? Daughter of ? And Margaret
Stewart Andrew A.   1912  
Stewart Albert A.   1912?  
Stewart Lawrence ? ?  
Stewart Clary ? ?  
Sons of R. H. & Ann Stewart (Stones almost obliterated)
Stillson Rocksey Ann   2/26/1887 Wife of Wm. L. Stilson
Stillson William ? ? Co. "F" (?) Ohio Inf. (Stone Obliterated) Civil War Soldier (Section C Row 12)
Swanston Simon 1828 1854 Born near Pettigo, Ireland
Sweeney Francis 12/23/1853 4/20/1890  
Tidswell John   8/2/1859 Aged 21 years
Tidswell Catherine   11/11/1887 Mother
Treaster Sarah C. 1854 1904 Mother
Treaster Alexander 1850 1923 Father
Treaster Cora M. 1879 1962  
Treaster George A. 1883 1947  
Treester Frank W. 1868 1912  
Treester James    ? ? Corporal, Co. "G" 171 Ohio Inf. Civil War Soldier (Section C Row 6)
Treester Lucinda O. 1838 1918 Wife of James Treester
Treester Mary Helen 1836 1846 Born of J.G. & M.A. Treester
Treester Gray W. 1868 1912  
Treester Lucinda 1838 1918 Wife of James Trester
Twigg Emma M. 1885 1950  
Twigg John J. 1880 1942  
Vail William M. 1887 1941  
Vail James W. 1847 1931  
Vail Jane Miller 1848 1924 Wife of J.W.
Vail Jacob   3/15/1878  
Vail Letitia   1876 73 years old
Vail William   4/5/1882 58 years, 10 months, 18 days, Civil War Soldier (G.A.R) (Section C Row 11)
Vail Elizabeth   12/9/1892 Wife of Wm. Vail, 77 years
Vail Mary J. 2/29/1844 4/9/1926  
Vail Elizabeth R.  4/7/1856 1/6/1927  
Vail Andrew 10/6/1854 9/4/1890  
Vail Susannah   6/27/1863 20 years, 5 months, 18 days; Daughter
Vail George   6/12/1874 26 years, 10 months, 6 days
Vail Annie M. 11/4/1868 6/28/1934  
Vail Maria H. 6/2/1828 11/28/1921  
Vail Laura 5/19/1872 11/28/1896  
Vail Hiram J. 4/10/1838 11/30/1912 Co. 170 V.T. Civil War Soldier (Section C Row 12)
Wardle Elizabeth Ann 1818 1894  
Wardle Charles   1841 1930  
Wardle Mary 1847 1934  
Wardle Minnie 1871 1886  
Wardle Mary 1869 1892  
Wardle Charles 1879 1954  
Wardle Ralph L. 1885 1948  
Wardle Ada S. 1884 1965  
Warner Thomas 1890 1929  
Warner Rebecca 1839 1909  
Weaver William 1921 1963  
Williams David M. 1862 1896  
Williams Bonnie B. 2/6/1906 4/22/1968  
Williams Raymond J. 6/11/1892 4/1/1969 WWI Veteran (Row 6, Section A)
Williams Nellie E. 5/22/1892 12/20/1972  
Williams Rowland E.  8/18/1889 7/7/1969  
Williamson Dora M. 1864 1928  
Wilson Anice 1884 1968  
Wilson Archie 1881 1944  
Wilson Estella 1907 1908  
Winecar Hannah      9/5/1848  
Winecar Alvin   9/26/1848  
Yost Bessie M. 1870 1950  
Yost Dr. J. O. 1867 1905  

 

Top of page

If you'd like to make a donation, please click the link below

PayPal Link and Image

This page is maintained by Michael J. Witt, Jr., Webmaster.  Email me here.

This list was updated on 5/09/2008 at 10:34 AM. Send submissions to the email above.